People with serious mental illness are disproportionately likely to be killed or injured in encounters with police. The Treatment Advocacy Center has estimated that roughly a quarter of people killed in police encounters in the US have an untreated serious mental illness. The reasons are not mysterious — police are trained primarily for confrontation, not de-escalation, and the behaviours of acute psychosis can be misread as defiance. This article is a harm-reduction guide. It is not legal advice, and it is not meant to suggest the responsibility for safety lies with the patient. It is meant to give people and families practical ways to lower the temperature of an encounter that is, in too many places, still inadequately equipped to handle them.
The single most protective step is to avoid calling 911 unless absolutely necessary, and when you must, to ask explicitly for a CIT-trained officer or mobile crisis team — and to prepare in advance for the encounter you hope you never have.
Before any crisis: prepare
Know your alternatives to 911
- 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline — phone, text, and chat. Most calls do not result in any in-person dispatch. See our 988 deep dive.
- Mobile crisis teams — many counties have mental health professionals who respond to crises without police. Search "mobile crisis team [your county]." See our mobile crisis teams overview.
- Local warm lines — peer-staffed lines for non-emergency support. See our warm line article.
- Crisis stabilisation units in some areas accept walk-ins. See our overview.
- Programs like CAHOOTS in Eugene, Oregon, dispatch unarmed crisis responders instead of police for many calls. Similar programs are growing in other cities.
Have a card you can show
A laminated wallet card identifying you as having schizophrenia, listing your psychiatrist, your medications, and an emergency contact, can change the framing of an encounter immediately. Some advocacy organisations distribute these cards. The information helps an officer see a patient rather than a suspect.
Tell your local police you exist
In many jurisdictions, families can register a person with serious mental illness on a "special needs" registry that flags addresses for dispatchers. The dispatcher can then send a CIT-trained officer or mobile crisis team. Not all jurisdictions have this, but where it exists it is worth using.
Make a psychiatric advance directive
A PAD does not bind police, but it can guide what happens after the encounter — which hospital, which medications, which contact person. See our PAD article.
If you must call for help
Open the call clearly
- "My family member has schizophrenia and is having a mental health crisis. Please send a CIT-trained officer or mobile crisis team."
- "They are not violent. There are no weapons in the home."
- "They are confused, not dangerous."
- "Please ask responders to approach calmly, no sirens, no drawn weapons."
Stay on the line
Dispatchers can pass details to responding officers in real time. Use the call to keep adding context: how the person is responding, where they are, what they are saying.
Meet officers outside if you can
Brief them before they enter. Tell them what to expect, what works for the person, what to avoid. Ask them to keep their voices low and stay calm.
For the person with schizophrenia
If you are reading this in a calmer moment and want to prepare for a future encounter:
- Comply visibly even when commands feel meaningless. Slow movements. Open hands. Verbal confirmation: "I am putting my hands up. I am going to stand still."
- Identify yourself early. "I have schizophrenia. I am not armed. I take medication for this."
- Do not try to explain delusions. The encounter is not the moment to be understood; it is the moment to get through.
- Do not run. Even if you are frightened. Sudden movement is dangerously easy to misread.
- Ask for a CIT officer. "Is there a CIT officer available?" tells the responding officer you know what that is.
- Carry medical info. A wallet card or a phone lock-screen note with the diagnosis, medications, and emergency contact.
For families and bystanders
- Do not crowd the officers or the person
- Lower your voice; the encounter often de-escalates with vocal modeling
- Avoid arguing with delusional content in front of officers
- Document what you can — date, time, badge numbers, witnesses
- Do not consent to searches or interviews if you do not feel safe doing so
If something goes wrong
- Document everything as soon as possible — names, badge numbers, times, witnesses
- Request medical records from the hospital, if there was one
- File a complaint with the police department's internal affairs office
- Contact your state's Protection and Advocacy organisation (find yours)
- Contact a civil rights attorney for serious incidents
Most mental health crises do not require police. 988, mobile crisis teams, and warm lines exist precisely so the default response is not law enforcement. Call 911 only if there is immediate danger that cannot be addressed otherwise.
Bigger picture
Cities with strong CIT programs, mobile crisis teams, and 988 infrastructure have measurably fewer harmful police-mental health encounters. None of this is the patient's fault. The harm-reduction strategies in this article exist because the system is still catching up — not because the responsibility for safety lies with the person in crisis.
For more, see our articles on CIT officers, the CAHOOTS model, and when to call 911 for mental health.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified mental health professional. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988 in the US, or your local emergency number.